TL;DR
Get kitchen gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Good Housekeeping’s Kitchen Lab report recommends nonstick skillets from Circulon, Tramontina, Le Creuset, GreenPan and All-Clad after repeated cooking and heat-distribution tests. The picks differ in price, oven-safe temperature and upkeep, and the report notes that ceramic coatings may wear faster than traditional nonstick.
Good Housekeeping’s Kitchen Lab has named five nonstick skillets as standouts after testing them for tasks including frying eggs, searing steak and distributing heat. The report compares Circulon, Tramontina, Le Creuset, GreenPan and All-Clad, giving shoppers practical differences in oven limits, handling, cleanup and expected coating wear rather than identifying one pan as best for every kitchen.
The report describes the 10-inch Circulon skillet as a balanced, reasonably priced option. In tests, fried and scrambled eggs released easily, and a flour-based heat test showed even coloring across the cooking surface. Good Housekeeping says the pan has held up to regular use without staining or chipping, while its silicone-covered handle limits oven use to 400°F. The source lists it as made without PFOA.
Tramontina’s 10-inch pan has sloped sides, a silicone grip and a smooth, rivetless interior that is easier to clean. The report says steaks seared evenly and eggs released with a small nudge and no oil. Its exterior stained during use, a cosmetic drawback noted by the testers. It is also rated for ovens up to 400°F and is listed as made without PFOA.
The remaining picks trade cost and construction for different performance features. Good Housekeeping says Le Creuset’s hard-anodized skillet released eggs readily, seared steak evenly and can go into a 500°F oven, but costs more and is heavier than many tested pans. The GreenPan Valencia Pro earned high marks for heat distribution and has the list’s highest stated oven limit, 600°F; the report cautions that ceramic nonstick may show wear sooner. The supplied source also praises the All-Clad skillet’s wide base and even searing, though its account of that pan’s test results is incomplete.
How the Picks Differ in Use
The results matter because nonstick pans are often bought for convenience, but their performance and limitations vary. Oven-safe temperature affects which recipes can move from stovetop to oven, while pan weight and handle design influence day-to-day handling. A lower-cost pan may suit basic egg cooking, whereas cooks who often sear meat or finish dishes in the oven may prioritize a wider cooking surface or higher temperature rating.
The report also gives readers a reason to weigh upkeep against convenience. Its GreenPan assessment says the ceramic surface performed well in testing, but may wear faster than traditional nonstick. Good Housekeeping says careful use, including avoiding abrasive utensils and hand-washing, helped its Kitchen Lab pan remain in good shape after more than three years. That is an observation about its own use, not a guarantee of service life for every buyer.
Products Worth Considering
Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Round Bread Oven, 9.5-Inch, Cerise
Philips 2200 Series Fully Automatic Espresso Machine with Classic Milk Frother, 2 Coffee Varieties, Intuitive Touch Display, Ceramic Grinder
Traeger Woodridge Pro Wood Pellet Grill and Smoker, 970 sq. in.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Testing Behind the Recommendations
The roundup draws on both controlled Kitchen Lab tests and ongoing use. The described tests include cooking fried and scrambled eggs, evaluating heat distribution by observing flour color on the pan, and searing steak. The source also reports that some pans have been used in the test kitchen for extended periods, including more than a year for Le Creuset and over three years for GreenPan.
Those methods help explain why the list does not rely on a single measure. Easy egg release is useful for everyday cooking, but it does not by itself indicate how well a pan sears, cleans up or tolerates oven heat. The supplied material presents a selection of product assessments, not a complete account of every pan tested or a standardized lifespan comparison.
“Ceramic tends to wear faster than traditional nonstick.”
— Good Housekeeping’s report on GreenPan Valencia Pro
What the Product Tests Don’t Settle
The supplied report does not state its publication date, the full testing protocol, or how many pans of each model were tested. It also does not provide a direct, controlled comparison of how long each coating lasts or set out a single overall winner. The All-Clad description ends before its complete performance account, so its results cannot be fully summarized from the material provided.
Oven ratings and test outcomes are reported by Good Housekeeping, but the source excerpt does not provide independent verification or details on how each rating was established. Prices and discounts can change; the material mentions promotional offers for some products but gives no stable price comparison across all five picks.
Check Fit Before Buying
Readers comparing these skillets should check current product specifications and prices before purchasing, particularly the oven-safe limit, pan dimensions and handle material. The report’s findings can help narrow choices by cooking style, but its evidence does not establish a universal best pan or a guaranteed replacement schedule. Good Housekeeping’s source page contains the full product reviews, where available.
Key Questions
Which nonstick pan did Good Housekeeping recommend?
The report features five options: Circulon, Tramontina, Le Creuset, GreenPan Valencia Pro and All-Clad. It describes different strengths rather than naming one as the best choice for every cook.
Which pan has the highest stated oven-safe temperature?
The report lists the GreenPan Valencia Pro as oven-safe up to 600°F, the highest rating among the pans in the supplied material.
What drawback did testers note about the GreenPan?
Good Housekeeping says ceramic nonstick may wear faster than traditional nonstick. Its testers reported that food could stick more as the surface heated, while the pan remained in good shape after more than three years of careful Kitchen Lab use.
Are all five pans equally easy to clean?
No. The report praises Circulon’s coated rivets and Tramontina’s smooth, rivetless interior for easier cleanup. It says All-Clad’s rivets can be tricky to clean, and notes that Tramontina’s exterior stained.
Source: rss
