The best griddle grease management accessories depend on whether you need a simple liner, a better grease-capture setup, or a replacement cup. My best overall pick is the Blackstone 5188 Rear Grease Gate and Magnetic Tool Holder Combo, which pairs grease control with a useful tool-storage feature. For easier routine cleanup, the MOACOCK 50-Pack Aluminum Foil Drip Pan Liners offers a generous supply of disposable liners, while the Firsgrill Professional Replacement Blackstone Griddle Grease Cup suits buyers replacing the cup itself. The main tradeoff is between low-effort disposable parts, reusable components, and accessories that alter how grease flows. Read on for the full breakdown and advice on matching an accessory to your griddle and cooking habits.
Get kitchen gear delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The Blackstone 5188 combo earns the top spot because it combines a rear grease gate with a magnetic tool holder, adding more utility than a liner-only purchase.
- Disposable liners are the clearest low-maintenance choice. The roundup includes several pack sizes, so buyers can weigh replenishment frequency against storage and waste.
- Grease gates and drainage systems solve a different problem from liners. They guide or block grease movement; liners only help contain it after it reaches a compatible cup or tray.
- Compatibility matters more than a large pack count. Products aimed at Blackstone griddles dominate the list, while the MixRBBQ cup and liners are specified for Camp Chef griddles.
- Reusable liners and replacement cups suit different needs. Silicone or reusable aluminum options reduce reliance on disposable pans, while a replacement cup addresses worn or missing collection hardware.
| MOACOCK 50-Pack Aluminum Foil Drip Pan Liners for Blackstone Griddles |  | Best Bulk Pack | Brand: MOACOCK | Quantity: 50 liners | Material: Aluminum foil | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MeWeBlue Grease Catcher for Blackstone Griddles with 12 Aluminum Liners |  | Best Replacement Catcher for Multiple Hook Styles | Brand: MeWeBlue | Grease cup material: Alloy steel | Liner material: Aluminum | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Findful 30-Pack Disposable Aluminum Grease Cup Liners for Blackstone Griddles |  | Best for Broad Listed Size Coverage | Quantity: 30 liners | Material: Heavy-duty aluminum foil | Dimensions: 8 × 3 × 3.7 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Eveanro Rear Grease Drainage System for Blackstone Griddles |  | Best for Covered, Level-Visible Collection | Compatible griddle sizes: 36, 28, 22, and 17 inches, with model exclusions | Bucket capacity: 2 L | Hose length: 3.3 ft | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Sivsis Grease Catcher Kit for Blackstone Griddles |  | Best High-Capacity Catcher Kit | Bucket capacity: 2.3 L (0.6 gallon) | Hose length: 3.5 ft | Hose heat resistance: Up to 600°F | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Blackstone 5188 Rear Grease Gate and Magnetic Tool Holder Combo |  | Best Gate-and-Tool Combo | Material: Stainless steel | Included components: Rear grease gate and 3 magnetic hooks | Item weight: 0.35 kg | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Reusable Silicone Grease Cup Liners for Blackstone Griddles, 2-Pack, Orange |  | Best Reusable Liner Option | Brand: Oliggive | Material: Silicone | Quantity: 2 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Blackstone Grease Cup Liners, 10-Pack |  | Best Simple Disposable Liners | Material: Aluminum foil | Pack size: 10 liners | Capacity: 27 fl oz per liner | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Rear Grease Drainage System for Blackstone Griddles |  | Best for Enclosed Grease Collection | Brand: Trybuy | Material: Alloy steel | Color: Black | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Aoanoko Stainless Steel Magnetic Griddle Grease Gate Blocker, 1 Pack |  | Best Compact Magnetic Gate | Brand: Aoanoko | Material: Stainless steel | Color: Silver | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| NUPICK Reusable Aluminum Grease Cup Liners for Blackstone Griddles, 60 Pack |  | Best Overall for Eco-Friendly Grease Management | Brand: NUPICK | Quantity: 60 | Material: Aluminum | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Whaleme Disposable Grease Cup Liners for Blackstone Griddles, 30 Pack |  | Best Disposable for Quick, Easy Cleanup | Quantity: 30 liners | Material: Aluminum foil | Dimensions: 8 x 3 x 3.7 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MixRBBQ Grease Cup with 10 Aluminum Drip Pan Liners for Camp Chef Griddles, 24 oz |  | Best for Camp Chef Users Needing a Reusable Solution | Brand: MixRBBQ | Included components: 1 grease cup tray and 10 liners | Grease cup dimensions: 9 x 2.95 x 2.4 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 50-Pack Disposable Aluminum Grease Cup Liners for Blackstone Griddles |  | Best Bulk Disposable for High-Volume Use | Quantity: 50 liners | Material: Aluminum foil | Dimensions: 8 x 3 x 3.7 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Firsgrill Professional Replacement Blackstone Griddle Grease Cup |  | Best Tool-Free, Reusable Grease Cup for Blackstone | Brand: Firsgrill | Model Number: BSL | Number of Items: 1 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| griddle grease management accessorie | Material | Dimensions | Brand | Compatible griddle sizes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MOACOCK 50-Pack Aluminum Foil | Aluminum foil | 8 × 3.7 × 3 inches | MOACOCK | 17, 22, 28, 30, and 36 inches, subject to grease-cup fit |
| MeWeBlue Grease Catcher for Bl | — | — | MeWeBlue | Select 17-, 22-, 26-, and 28-inch Blackstone models |
| Findful 30-Pack Disposable Alu | Heavy-duty aluminum foil | 8 × 3 × 3.7 inches | — | 17, 22, 28, 30, and 36 inches |
| Eveanro Rear Grease Drainage S | — | 6.3 × 5.12 × 5.9 inches | — | 36, 28, 22, and 17 inches, with model exclusions |
| Sivsis Grease Catcher Kit for | — | — | — | Most Blackstone 17-, 22-, 28-, 28XL-, and 36-inch models |
| Blackstone 5188 Rear Grease Ga | Stainless steel | — | — | — |
| Reusable Silicone Grease Cup L | Silicone | 7 × 3.3 × 2.8 inches | Oliggive | 17, 22, 28, and 36 inches |
| Blackstone Grease Cup Liners | Aluminum foil | 8 × 3.75 × 3 inches | — | — |
| Rear Grease Drainage System fo | Alloy steel | — | Trybuy | — |
| Aoanoko Stainless Steel Magnet | Stainless steel | 5.5 × 1.5 × 0.3 inches | Aoanoko | — |
| NUPICK Reusable Aluminum Greas | Aluminum | 8 × 3 × 3.7 inches | NUPICK | — |
| Whaleme Disposable Grease Cup | Aluminum foil | 8 x 3 x 3.7 inches | — | 17, 22, 28, 30, and 36 inches |
| MixRBBQ Grease Cup with 10 Alu | — | — | MixRBBQ | — |
| 50-Pack Disposable Aluminum Gr | Aluminum foil | 8 x 3 x 3.7 inches | — | 28, 30, and 36 inches |
| Firsgrill Professional Replace | Metal | — | Firsgrill | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
MOACOCK 50-Pack Aluminum Foil Drip Pan Liners for Blackstone Griddles
For buyers who already have a compatible grease cup and want to avoid washing it after every cook, MOACOCK’s 50-pack puts disposable cleanup at the center of its value. The rectangular foil liners collect drippings, then can be removed for disposal; their extra uses for food prep, storage, broiling, and baking add flexibility beyond griddle maintenance. Compared with the Findful 30-pack, MOACOCK supplies more liners, while Findful lists a heavier-duty foil construction and may need slight bending on some 22-inch griddles. The main decision is fit: MOACOCK specifically excludes certain 28- and 36-inch griddles with a larger 5.5 × 3.5-inch side grease cup. These are liners, not a replacement catcher, so buyers without a compatible cup should choose a complete catcher kit instead.
Pros:- 50 liners reduce how often frequent cooks need to restock.
- Disposable design makes grease-cup cleanup simpler.
- Can also be used for food prep, storage, broiling, and baking.
- Aluminum foil is listed as recyclable.
Cons:- Does not include a grease cup or catcher.
- Does not fit certain 28- and 36-inch models with a larger side grease cup.
Best for: Blackstone owners with a compatible drip cup who cook often and want a larger supply of disposable liners.
Not ideal for: Owners of 28- or 36-inch griddles with the specified larger side grease cup, or anyone who needs a complete grease-catching system rather than liners.
- Brand:MOACOCK
- Quantity:50 liners
- Material:Aluminum foil
- Dimensions:8 × 3.7 × 3 inches
- Compatible griddle sizes:17, 22, 28, 30, and 36 inches, subject to grease-cup fit
- Shape:Rectangular
- Weight:16 ounces
- Recyclable:Yes
Our verdict“Choose MOACOCK for a high-quantity liner supply if your existing Blackstone grease cup matches its fit requirements.”
MeWeBlue Grease Catcher for Blackstone Griddles with 12 Aluminum Liners
The MeWeBlue is the lineup’s practical choice when the existing grease catcher needs replacing, rather than just relining. Its alloy steel cup has a smooth coating intended to make cleaning easier, and three hook styles offer a way to match different compatible griddle setups. That makes it more adaptable than MOACOCK or Findful, which supply liners only, but the included set has just 12 liners, so frequent cooks may need replacements sooner than with either bulk pack. Compatibility is the deciding drawback: the cup is for select 17-, 22-, 26-, and 28-inch Blackstone griddles, and the hook style must match. I’d choose this over a liner-only pack when a new catcher is needed, but not without checking the griddle model and attachment first.
Pros:- Provides a grease catcher as well as 12 aluminum liners.
- Three hook styles help match different compatible cup attachments.
- Smooth coating is intended to make the steel cup easier to clean.
- Included liners are recyclable aluminum.
Cons:- Compatibility is limited to select models and combinations.
- Buyers must match the hook style to their existing setup.
- Includes fewer liners than the MOACOCK and Findful packs.
Best for: Blackstone owners with a compatible 17-, 22-, 26-, or 28-inch model who need a replacement catcher and want several hook-style options.
Not ideal for: Owners who already have a functioning grease cup and only need liners, or buyers unable to confirm that a hook style and model are compatible.
- Brand:MeWeBlue
- Grease cup material:Alloy steel
- Liner material:Aluminum
- Compatible griddle sizes:Select 17-, 22-, 26-, and 28-inch Blackstone models
- Included liners:12
- Liner dimensions:7 × 3.2 × 2.8 inches
- Item weight:0.55 kg
- Model number:2522
Our verdict“Pick MeWeBlue when you need a replacement catcher and have verified the correct hook style for your Blackstone.”
Findful 30-Pack Disposable Aluminum Grease Cup Liners for Blackstone Griddles
Findful’s 30-pack suits buyers who want disposable liners listed for a wide range of Blackstone sizes, including 17-, 22-, 28-, 30-, and 36-inch models. The tool-free attachment keeps the changeover straightforward, and the heavy-duty foil liners can also serve as food containers or baking trays. Compared with MOACOCK, Findful includes fewer liners but lists the same broad size range; MOACOCK, however, specifies a compatibility exclusion for certain larger side grease cups, so buyers should check cup dimensions rather than relying on griddle size alone. Findful also notes that some 22-inch cups may need slight bending for fit. That caveat and the disposable format make this less suited to buyers seeking a precise, reusable solution, but it offers a simple way to reduce grease-cup scrubbing.
Pros:- 30 liners provide a useful supply for routine cooks.
- Attaches without tools for quick liner changes.
- Listed for 17-, 22-, 28-, 30-, and 36-inch Blackstone griddles.
- Can also be used for food storage or baking.
Cons:- Some 22-inch griddles may require slight bending for fit.
- Disposable liners create ongoing waste.
- Does not include a grease cup or catcher.
Best for: Blackstone owners who want tool-free disposable liners and need listed coverage across several griddle sizes.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want reusable grease management or a guaranteed no-adjustment fit, especially on a 22-inch model that may need liner bending.
- Quantity:30 liners
- Material:Heavy-duty aluminum foil
- Dimensions:8 × 3 × 3.7 inches
- Compatible griddle sizes:17, 22, 28, 30, and 36 inches
- Item weight:11.3 ounces
- Model number:88-JH-DYP-PT-30pack
- Attachment:Tool-free
- ASIN:B0B71Q8VM6
Our verdict“Choose Findful if you want a tool-free liner pack with broad listed size coverage and can accommodate a possible fit adjustment.”
Eveanro Rear Grease Drainage System for Blackstone Griddles
Eveanro takes grease collection beyond the small cup format: its rear drainage system routes drippings through a heat-resistant hose into a covered 2 L bucket, and the transparent lid lets owners check the fill level without opening it. That setup can keep an exposed grease cup and its contents less accessible around the grill. Compared with the Sivsis kit, Eveanro has a slightly smaller listed capacity and a lower hose heat-resistance rating, but it supplies installation hardware and a screwdriver alongside 12 liners. The tradeoff is a more involved installation and a longer compatibility checklist: several E-series and Culinary-series models, plus specific model numbers, are excluded. I’d favor it over simple foil liners for a fixed outdoor setup that needs contained collection, but not for buyers who want a quick drop-in replacement.
Pros:- Covered 2 L bucket keeps collected grease contained.
- Transparent lid allows a quick fill-level check.
- Includes a silicone hose, liners, clamps, screws, screwdriver, and installation manual.
- Heat-resistant hose can be cut to the desired length.
Cons:- Not compatible with several E-series and Culinary-series models and specified model numbers.
- Installation takes more effort than changing a disposable liner.
- Bucket capacity and hose heat rating are lower than those listed for the Sivsis kit.
Best for: Owners of compatible Blackstone griddles who want grease routed into a covered bucket and prefer a visible fill-level check.
Not ideal for: Owners of excluded E-series or Culinary-series models, or anyone who wants a liner-only option without installation steps.
- Compatible griddle sizes:36, 28, 22, and 17 inches, with model exclusions
- Bucket capacity:2 L
- Hose length:3.3 ft
- Hose heat resistance:Up to 570°F
- Materials:Powder-coated steel funnel, stainless steel grease gate, silicone hose
- Dimensions:6.3 × 5.12 × 5.9 inches
- Item weight:2.2 pounds
- Included liners:12 foil liners
Our verdict“Choose Eveanro for a compatible griddle when covered collection and a visible bucket level matter more than a quick, simple fit.”
Sivsis Grease Catcher Kit for Blackstone Griddles
For buyers who want to move grease away from the griddle’s rear exit, the Sivsis kit pairs a 2.3 L lidded bucket with a flexible hose and a movable stainless steel gate. Its capacity is larger than Eveanro’s 2 L bucket, and the hose is rated to a higher temperature, making Sivsis the stronger fit on those two specs for cooks who generate more drippings. The magnetic attachment and flexible placement can make setup less dependent on fixed mounting points, while the gate is designed to keep food and debris out of the hose. The limits are fit and access: compatibility is stated for most listed Blackstone sizes, not every model, and rear grease-exit mounting may be awkward on some setups. It’s a more involved choice than MOACOCK or Findful liners, but those packs cannot route grease into a lidded bucket.
Pros:- 2.3 L lidded bucket holds more than the Eveanro system’s 2 L bucket.
- Magnetic attachment and flexible hose support convenient placement.
- Movable stainless steel gate helps keep food and debris out of the hose.
- Listed for most Blackstone 17-, 22-, 28-, 28XL-, and 36-inch models.
Cons:- Does not fit every Blackstone model, including several named exclusions.
- Rear grease-exit access can make installation difficult on some setups.
- More involved than replacing a disposable liner in an existing cup.
Best for: Frequent griddle cooks with a compatible Blackstone who want a larger lidded grease bucket and flexible hose placement.
Not ideal for: Owners of excluded E-series, Culinary-series, or specified Blackstone models, and buyers whose rear grease exit is hard to reach.
- Bucket capacity:2.3 L (0.6 gallon)
- Hose length:3.5 ft
- Hose heat resistance:Up to 600°F
- Compatible griddle sizes:Most Blackstone 17-, 22-, 28-, 28XL-, and 36-inch models
- Materials:Powder-coated carbon steel, 304 stainless steel gate, silicone hose
- Product dimensions:4.7 × 2.6 × 5.2 inches
- Item weight:2.6 pounds
- Model number:GDB
Our verdict“Choose Sivsis if your model is compatible and you want a higher-capacity lidded bucket with flexible hose placement.”
Blackstone 5188 Rear Grease Gate and Magnetic Tool Holder Combo
The Blackstone 5188 pairs two useful jobs: its rear gate helps stop food scraps from dropping into the grease trap while still letting grease drain, and three magnetic hooks keep utensils close at hand. That makes it a more functional pick than the Aoanoko Stainless Steel Magnetic Griddle Grease Gate Blocker, which focuses on blocking food rather than adding tool storage. The tradeoff is fit: this combo requires a griddle with a compatible rear grease opening, so it is not a universal cleanup accessory. Its stainless steel components are dishwasher safe, which can simplify cleanup after cooking, though buyers seeking to route grease into a covered container will get more containment from the Trybuy Rear Grease Drainage System. I’d choose this for a compatible setup where preventing food loss and organizing tools matter more than enclosing the grease.
Pros:- Gate helps keep food from falling into the rear grease trap while allowing grease to drain.
- Three magnetic hooks provide convenient utensil storage.
- Stainless steel components are dishwasher safe.
- Combines grease-area protection and tool organization in one set.
Cons:- Requires a compatible rear grease opening.
- Does not include a hose, bucket, or other enclosed grease-containment system.
Best for: Blackstone owners with a compatible rear grease opening who want a food-catching gate and nearby utensil hooks in one accessory.
Not ideal for: Owners of griddles without a compatible rear grease opening, or cooks who need an enclosed bucket and hose to contain grease.
- Material:Stainless steel
- Included components:Rear grease gate and 3 magnetic hooks
- Item weight:0.35 kg
- Model number:5188
- Recommended use:Cookware
- Indoor/outdoor use:Outdoor
- Warranty:Limited 1-year manufacturer warranty
Our verdict“Choose this combo if your griddle fits it and you want a grease gate plus utensil hooks, rather than a full drainage kit.”
Reusable Silicone Grease Cup Liners for Blackstone Griddles, 2-Pack, Orange
These two flexible silicone liners suit Blackstone owners who would rather wash and reuse a drip-catching insert than keep replacing foil. They are listed for 17-, 22-, 28-, and 36-inch griddles, and hand-washing or dishwasher cleaning gives buyers a choice after cooking. Compared with the disposable Blackstone Grease Cup Liners, 10-Pack, this pair avoids tossing a liner whenever it fills, but it does require regular cleaning instead of quick disposal. The orange color makes the liners easy to spot, while their flexibility may help with handling; still, the product data does not establish compatibility beyond the named Blackstone sizes. I’d pick these for frequent cooks comfortable washing grease residue, not for anyone who prioritizes the simplest possible cleanup or wants a large disposable supply.
Pros:- Reusable alternative to disposable foil liners.
- Flexible silicone is designed to catch grease drips and help reduce mess.
- Can be hand-washed or cleaned in a dishwasher.
- Listed compatibility covers 17-, 22-, 28-, and 36-inch Blackstone griddles.
Cons:- Requires cleaning after use rather than disposal.
- Compatibility is described specifically for Blackstone griddles.
- The two-piece set offers less ready-to-use backup capacity than a multi-liner disposable pack.
Best for: Frequent Blackstone cooks with a listed griddle size who want reusable liners and are willing to wash them after use.
Not ideal for: Cooks who prefer to discard a full liner, or owners of griddles outside the listed Blackstone sizes.
- Brand:Oliggive
- Material:Silicone
- Quantity:2
- Dimensions:7 × 3.3 × 2.8 inches
- Compatible griddle sizes:17, 22, 28, and 36 inches
- Color:Orange
- Item weight:703 g
- Model number:GCL-2PCS
Our verdict“Choose these if you want reusable grease-cup liners for a listed Blackstone size and do not mind washing them.”
Blackstone Grease Cup Liners, 10-Pack
The Blackstone 5017 liners keep grease cleanup straightforward: place one in a compatible grease cup, collect drippings, then remove and discard it when full. Each liner holds up to 27 fl oz, a useful capacity for reducing how often it needs changing during a cook. Compared with the Oliggive reusable silicone liners, this pack trades repeated washing for quick disposal; compared with a drainage kit such as the Trybuy system, it does not route grease into a lidded bucket. The foil construction is described as sturdy and leak-resistant, but these remain single-use inserts, and fit is limited to the listed Blackstone models and cups. I’d choose them for cooks who value simple cleanup over reusability and have a confirmed compatible grease cup.
Pros:- Disposable design makes removal and cleanup simple.
- Each liner holds up to 27 fl oz.
- Foil construction is designed to resist bending and leaks.
- Listed fit covers several Blackstone griddles and product lines.
Cons:- Single-use liners need replacement when full.
- Designed for compatible Blackstone grease cups rather than universal fit.
- Does not provide a hose or enclosed grease container.
Best for: Blackstone owners with a compatible grease cup who want a straightforward disposable insert with substantial stated capacity.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking reusable liners, owners of unlisted griddle models, or cooks who want grease routed to an enclosed bucket.
- Material:Aluminum foil
- Pack size:10 liners
- Capacity:27 fl oz per liner
- Dimensions:8 × 3.75 × 3 inches
- Compatibility:36-inch, 28-inch, and 17-inch griddles, Range Top Combo, and ProSeries models
- Model number:5017
- Recyclable:Yes
Our verdict“Pick this pack for easy disposal and generous stated capacity if your Blackstone grease cup is among the compatible models.”
Rear Grease Drainage System for Blackstone Griddles
For cooks who want to move grease away from the griddle and into a covered container, the Trybuy drainage system is the most complete option in this group. Its funnel and integrated gate catch debris, while a 3.5-foot hose carries grease to a lidded 60-ounce bucket; 12 foil liners are included to simplify emptying. That is a bigger setup than the Blackstone 5188 gate-and-hook combo, which protects the rear opening and stores tools but does not enclose grease. The added containment comes with strict compatibility limits: it needs a rear grease exit and excludes E-Series and several named models. Buyers should verify their exact griddle before choosing it. I’d favor this kit for compatible outdoor cooks who want a bucket placed away from the drain, but skip it if a simple cup liner is enough.
Pros:- Lidded 60-ounce bucket helps contain collected grease.
- A 3.5-foot hose allows the bucket to sit away from the griddle opening.
- Integrated gate helps catch food scraps before they enter the hose.
- Includes 12 foil liners for the bucket.
Cons:- Requires a compatible rear grease exit.
- Does not fit E-Series and several specifically listed Blackstone models.
- More components to install and manage than a simple cup liner.
Best for: Owners of compatible rear-exit Blackstone griddles who want grease routed through a hose into a lidded bucket.
Not ideal for: Owners of E-Series or listed excluded models, griddles without a rear grease exit, or buyers seeking only a basic grease-cup liner.
- Brand:Trybuy
- Material:Alloy steel
- Color:Black
- Bucket capacity:60 oz (0.6 gallons)
- Hose length:3.5 ft
- Hose heat resistance:Up to 572°F
- Foil liner heat resistance:Up to 482°F
- Included liners:12
- Compatibility:Blackstone rear grease exit models 17, 22, 28, and 36 inches; excludes E-Series and models 1891, 1899, 1933, 2015, 2151, and 2230
Our verdict“Choose this kit if your Blackstone has a compatible rear exit and you want a hose-fed, lidded grease bucket rather than a basic liner.”
Aoanoko Stainless Steel Magnetic Griddle Grease Gate Blocker, 1 Pack
The Aoanoko magnetic gate is a compact way to keep food from sliding into a rear grease trap without adding a hose, bucket, or utensil hooks. Its magnetic attachment allows quick repositioning, while the stainless steel screen is described as easy to clean and rust-resistant. Compared with the Blackstone 5188 combo, this pick is simpler and lighter on add-ons, but gives up the three magnetic hooks. It also does less than the Trybuy drainage system: it blocks food at the opening rather than directing grease into a lidded container. The key limitation is material compatibility; it will not attach to aluminum or other non-magnetic griddles, and buyers need to check dimensions against their setup. I’d choose it for a magnetic griddle that needs a basic, repositionable barrier, not as a universal grease-management fix.
Pros:- Magnetic attachment allows quick installation and repositioning.
- Helps prevent food from falling into the rear grease trap.
- Stainless steel construction is described as rust-resistant and easy to clean.
- Compact dimensions suit buyers seeking a simple barrier rather than a full kit.
Cons:- Does not work with aluminum or other non-magnetic griddles.
- Buyers need to check the dimensions for a suitable fit.
- Does not collect or enclose grease, and includes no utensil hooks.
Best for: Owners of magnetic griddles who want a small, repositionable screen to keep food scraps out of the rear grease trap.
Not ideal for: Owners of aluminum or other non-magnetic griddles, or cooks needing a grease hose, bucket, or utensil hooks.
- Brand:Aoanoko
- Material:Stainless steel
- Color:Silver
- Shape:Rectangular
- Dimensions:5.5 × 1.5 × 0.3 inches
- Weight:0.17 kg
- Included component:Magnet
- Quantity:1
- Compatibility:Magnetic griddles; not compatible with aluminum or other non-magnetic griddles
Our verdict“Choose this compact gate if your griddle is magnetic and you only need a repositionable barrier at the rear grease opening.”
NUPICK Reusable Aluminum Grease Cup Liners for Blackstone Griddles, 60 Pack
This set stands out for its reusable design, which offers a sustainable alternative to disposable liners like the Whaleme 50-Pack. Its non-stick coating simplifies cleaning, and its compatibility with various Blackstone models makes it versatile. Compared to single-use options, the NUPICK liners reduce waste and ongoing costs, but require thorough cleaning between uses, which could be inconvenient for some. The ability to withstand temperatures up to 500°F ensures durability during high-heat cooking, making it a solid choice for frequent griddlers. However, since compatibility isn’t explicitly confirmed for every size in the title, buyers should double-check their griddle dimensions. Ideal for eco-conscious users who want a durable, reusable solution that cuts waste.
Pros:- Reusable design reduces waste and ongoing costs
- Non-stick coating eases cleanup
- Compatible with multiple Blackstone griddle models
- Withstands high temperatures up to 500°F
Cons:- Requires cleaning between uses, which may be inconvenient
- Compatibility details do not list all sizes explicitly
Best for: Families or frequent griddlers seeking a reusable, environmentally friendly grease management accessory.
Not ideal for: Casual users or those preferring disposable liners for quick cleanup without maintenance.
- Brand:NUPICK
- Quantity:60
- Material:Aluminum
- Dimensions:8 × 3 × 3.7 inches
- Maximum temperature:500°F
- Compatibility:Blackstone 36-inch, 28-inch, 17-inch, Range Top Combo, and Pro Series
Our verdict“This pick makes the most sense for eco-conscious users who want a durable, reusable grease management option for Blackstone griddles.”
Whaleme Disposable Grease Cup Liners for Blackstone Griddles, 30 Pack
This set is designed for convenience, with lightweight aluminum foil liners that catch grease and food drippings, making cleanup swift—especially compared with the more durable but cleaning-intensive NUPICK liners. Its compatibility with a broad range of Blackstone sizes, including 28-, 30-, and 36-inch models, makes it a flexible choice, although some models like 17- and 22-inch may require bending for a proper fit. Compared to the 50-pack from Whaleme, this 30-pack offers a more manageable quantity for occasional use, but the disposability means ongoing purchases are necessary. These liners are recyclable and can be used in ovens and freezers, adding versatility. The main tradeoff is the need to replace them after each use, which might not suit those seeking an eco-friendly approach. Best suited for users who prioritize quick cleanup and disposable convenience.
Pros:- Lightweight and disposable for quick cleanup
- Recyclable aluminum foil material
- Fits multiple Blackstone sizes
- Versatile for oven, freezer, and grilling use
Cons:- May need bending to fit smaller griddles like 17- and 22-inch
- Disposable nature increases ongoing waste and costs
Best for: Casual grillers or occasional users who want fast cleanup without maintenance.
Not ideal for: Frequent griddlers or eco-conscious buyers preferring reusable options due to waste concerns.
- Quantity:30 liners
- Material:Aluminum foil
- Dimensions:8 x 3 x 3.7 inches
- Compatible griddle sizes:17, 22, 28, 30, and 36 inches
- Weight:12.3 ounces
- Manufacturer:Whaleme
Our verdict“This option makes sense for users who need quick, disposable liners for occasional Blackstone griddle use.”
MixRBBQ Grease Cup with 10 Aluminum Drip Pan Liners for Camp Chef Griddles, 24 oz
Compared to the single-use options like Whaleme 30-Pack, the MixRBBQ set offers a reusable coated steel grease cup paired with recyclable liners, combining durability with convenience. The grease cup holds up to 24 oz, suitable for longer cooking sessions, and the liners make grease disposal straightforward. Its compatibility with multiple Camp Chef models makes it a practical choice for those with specific equipment, although buyers should verify dimensions before purchasing. The steel grease cup’s durability ensures longevity, but it’s limited to Camp Chef products, unlike the Firsgrill, which attaches directly to Blackstone. The liner set simplifies cleanup but adds another component to manage. Overall, it balances reusability with disposable liners for efficient grease management. Ideal for Camp Chef griddlers who want a durable, reusable grease catch with disposable liners for easy cleanup.
Pros:- Includes 10 recyclable liners for easy disposal
- Durable coated steel grease cup for long-term use
- Holds a substantial 24 oz of grease
- Fits several Camp Chef models
Cons:- Limited to specific Camp Chef models
- Compatibility check needed before purchase
Best for: Camp Chef users seeking a durable, reusable grease management system with disposable liners.
Not ideal for: Blackstone griddle owners or those preferring tool-free attachments or universal compatibility.
- Brand:MixRBBQ
- Included components:1 grease cup tray and 10 liners
- Grease cup dimensions:9 x 2.95 x 2.4 inches
- Liner dimensions:8.4 x 3.15 x 2.2 inches
- Capacity:24 oz
- Compatible models:Camp Chef SG100, SG90, SG60, SG30, SG14
Our verdict“This pick suits Camp Chef owners wanting a robust, reusable grease cup with disposable liners for simple maintenance.”
50-Pack Disposable Aluminum Grease Cup Liners for Blackstone Griddles
This set offers an economical bulk solution for frequent griddlers, with 50 stackable aluminum liners that fit 28-, 30-, and 36-inch Blackstone models. Their large pack size makes them ideal for busy commercial setups or large family gatherings, where frequent changing is necessary. Compared to smaller packs like the 30-pack from Whaleme, this provides a higher capacity for continuous use without constant reordering. The liners are versatile enough for oven, freezer, and baking tasks, adding value beyond griddle cleanup. However, for smaller griddles like 17- and 22-inch models, buyers may need to bend the liners to fit properly. The key tradeoff involves ongoing waste, as these are disposable, which may be less appealing for eco-conscious users. This bulk pack is best suited for high-volume users who prioritize cost-effective, quick cleanup.
Pros:- Pack of 50 liners for extensive use
- Fits multiple large griddle sizes
- Stackable for easy storage
- Suitable for oven and freezer use
Cons:- May require bending to fit smaller griddles
- Disposable nature leads to ongoing waste
Best for: Large households, commercial kitchens, or outdoor event setups with frequent griddle use.
Not ideal for: Small-scale users or those seeking eco-friendly, reusable options.
- Quantity:50 liners
- Material:Aluminum foil
- Dimensions:8 x 3 x 3.7 inches
- Compatible griddle sizes:28, 30, and 36 inches
- Weight:1.26 pounds
- Manufacturer:Whaleme
Our verdict“This bulk disposable option works best for heavy use environments where quick, economical cleanup outweighs waste concerns.”
Firsgrill Professional Replacement Blackstone Griddle Grease Cup
This grease cup makes managing grease effortless with its tool-free attachment, allowing it to be easily secured to the side shelf or lip of any Blackstone griddle—outperforming the need for separate liners or complex setups like the MixRBBQ. Its durable metal construction promises longevity, and being dishwasher safe simplifies cleanup, unlike disposable liners such as Whaleme or the bulk pack from Whaleme. The universal compatibility with sizes from 17 to 36 inches makes it highly versatile for Blackstone users. However, its exclusivity to Blackstone models limits its use for other griddle brands. For those who prefer a straightforward, reusable solution that minimizes waste, this grease cup offers a practical, tool-free upgrade. Best suited for Blackstone owners who want a durable, reusable, and easy-to-install grease management solution.
Pros:- Tool-free installation simplifies setup
- Durable metal construction for longevity
- Fits a wide range of Blackstone sizes
- Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning
Cons:- Only compatible with Blackstone brand griddles
- Limited to specific sizes, may not fit all models perfectly
Best for: Blackstone griddle owners seeking a durable, tool-free, reusable grease collection option.
Not ideal for: Users with non-Blackstone models or those preferring disposable liners for occasional use.
- Brand:Firsgrill
- Model Number:BSL
- Number of Items:1
- Included Components:Body and Liner
- Compatible Sizes:17″, 22″, 28″, 30″ & 36″
- Material:Metal
Our verdict“This pick is ideal for Blackstone users wanting a robust, reusable grease cup that installs quickly without tools.”
How We Picked
I ranked these accessories by how directly they address common grease-management jobs: catching grease, guiding its flow, replacing collection hardware, and reducing cleanup. I also weighed the buyer impact of fit, the type of material, whether a product is disposable or reusable, and whether it adds utility beyond grease control. A high pack count alone did not make a liner the strongest choice; compatibility and the role it serves matter more.
The Blackstone 5188 combo leads because it pairs a grease gate with a magnetic tool holder, giving it a broader role than cup liners. Disposable liners rank well for straightforward cleanup, while reusable liners and standalone grease cups serve buyers with different upkeep or replacement needs. Drainage systems and grease gates are judged as functional changes to grease flow, not as substitutes for a correctly sized collection cup. Product details provided identify intended griddle fit, but do not establish universal compatibility, so buyers should confirm their model and mounting arrangement before ordering.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Griddle Grease Management Accessories
Choose by tracing the whole grease path rather than starting with pack size. Grease must move from the cooking surface to a drain or gate, then into a cup or tray that can contain it safely. An accessory that solves only one part of that path may still leave you with spills or awkward cleanup.
Match the accessory to the problem you have
Start by identifying what is failing in your current setup: grease may miss the collection cup, the cup may be damaged, or cleanup may take too long. A liner addresses residue inside a compatible cup or pan, while a gate or drainage system affects where grease goes. Buying liners will not fix a blocked drain or a cup that does not sit securely. Likewise, a replacement cup does not automatically improve grease flow from the cooktop. Avoid buying multiple accessory types until you know which stage of collection is causing trouble.
Verify fit against your exact griddle
Do not rely on a brand name alone when checking fit. Griddles can differ by model, grease outlet position, cup shape, and accessory mounting points. Compare the accessory’s stated compatibility with your griddle’s model information and inspect the existing cup or drain before ordering. This matters especially for gates and drainage systems, which must align with the grease path, and for liners, which need to sit inside the intended cup or tray. A small mismatch can lead to movement, poor collection, or grease escaping where the accessory cannot catch it.
Choose disposable or reusable based on your cleanup routine
Disposable aluminum liners make removal straightforward, but they create ongoing replacements and used material to discard. Reusable silicone or aluminum liners reduce dependence on a fresh disposable pan, though they add washing and storage to the routine. Think about whether you can clean a reusable liner soon after cooking and where it will dry without collecting dust or grease. A large disposable pack can suit frequent cooks, but it is less useful if the liners are the wrong size or pile up unused. Pick the material that fits your actual cleanup habits, not an assumption that one type requires no maintenance.
Look beyond pack count when comparing liners
Pack size can shape how often you need to restock, but it says little about fit or everyday convenience. Check whether the product is a liner alone, a catcher with liners, or a replacement grease cup bundled with liners; these are different purchases. Bundles can be useful when you need the main hardware, while a large liner pack makes more sense if your existing cup is in good condition. Confirm dimensions and intended use before treating two similarly named packs as interchangeable. The right comparison is the cost and effort of the whole cleanup system, not the number of pieces by itself.
Know when a grease gate or drainage system is worth adding
A gate or drainage accessory may help when grease escapes the intended route or when you want to manage flow at the rear of the griddle. These parts do not replace a collection vessel, so check that your cup or tray can still catch what the accessory redirects. A magnetic blocker may be easier to position than a replacement drainage assembly, but the two styles do not necessarily serve the same purpose. Before buying, consider how the part attaches, whether it interferes with existing tools or surfaces, and how it will be cleaned. Pay more attention to a clear compatibility match and a complete grease path than to added features that do not solve your specific issue.
Buy replacement hardware only when the original part is the issue
If the grease cup is cracked, missing, or no longer sits properly, replacing the cup is more direct than trying to compensate with extra liners. If the cup works but is messy to empty, a liner may be the simpler change. Check the replacement cup’s stated fit and capacity against your current setup, and think about how often you cook before deciding whether capacity is a priority. A larger vessel can mean fewer interruptions, but only if it fits the griddle and can be removed and emptied comfortably. This distinction helps prevent buying an accessory that adds another layer without fixing the actual problem.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I buy a grease cup, a liner, or both?
Buy a cup if your existing collection vessel is missing, damaged, or incompatible with the griddle. A liner is meant to sit inside a compatible cup or pan and make residue easier to remove; it is not a substitute for the vessel itself. If your cup works but cleanup is the hassle, start with a correctly sized liner. If grease is escaping before it reaches the cup, a gate or drainage accessory may address the problem more directly. Check the full path from griddle outlet to collection vessel before adding parts.
Are Blackstone grease accessories compatible with every Blackstone griddle?
No single brand label confirms fit across every model. The outlet location, cup dimensions, mounting points, and rear layout can differ, so check the accessory’s listed compatibility against your griddle’s model details. This is especially important for gates and drainage systems, which need to align with the grease outlet. Liners also need to match the size and shape of the cup or tray they enter. If the product details do not identify your model or dimensions, compare them with your existing part before ordering.
When should I choose a reusable liner instead of disposable aluminum liners?
A reusable liner makes sense if you want to reduce the number of disposable pans you use and are willing to wash and store the part. Disposable aluminum liners are more convenient to remove and discard, but they need replenishing and create waste. Reusable choices do not remove cleaning from the job; they shift it from replacing a liner to washing one. Consider how often you cook and whether you can clean the liner promptly after use. Also confirm that the reusable material and shape suit your cup before choosing it over a disposable pack.
Will a grease gate eliminate the need for a grease cup?
No. A grease gate can help manage or redirect grease, but the grease still needs a suitable cup or tray to collect it. Think of the gate as one part of the route rather than the final container. If the collection vessel is missing, undersized, or poorly fitted, adding a gate alone may not prevent spills. Check that the gate aligns with the outlet and directs grease into the vessel you plan to use. For persistent overflow, review both the flow path and the cup’s fit instead of assuming one accessory can solve everything.
Is a large liner pack always a better choice for frequent griddle cooking?
Not necessarily. A larger pack can reduce how often you need to restock, but it only helps if the liners fit your collection cup and suit your preferred cleanup routine. Compare the product’s intended griddle compatibility and whether it is a liner-only pack or part of a hardware bundle. If your cup needs replacing, buying many liners first may leave the main problem unsolved. Frequent cooks may also prefer a reusable liner if they are comfortable washing it. Choose based on fit, the condition of your current hardware, and how you want to handle cleanup.
Conclusion
For most buyers, I recommend the Blackstone 5188 Rear Grease Gate and Magnetic Tool Holder Combo as the best overall pick because it combines grease management with extra tool storage. The MOACOCK 50-Pack Aluminum Foil Drip Pan Liners is my best value-style choice for buyers who already have a compatible cup and want a ready supply of disposable liners. For a premium-oriented setup, choose the Blackstone 5188 combo if its added gate and holder suit your griddle; for beginners, a compatible disposable liner pack is the simplest place to start. Buyers seeking a reusable option can compare the silicone and reusable aluminum liners, while those with a damaged cup should look at the Firsgrill replacement grease cup. Camp Chef owners should focus on the MixRBBQ cup and liners, and anyone considering a drainage system should verify exact model fit before buying.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
