For chestnut roasting on a standard stovetop, the KitchenCraft Carbon Steel Chestnut Roasting Pan is my strongest all-round pick: its perforated base vents steam, and its long wooden handle helps keep hands away from heat. For open-fire cooking, I favor the Esschert Design FF156, a cast-iron option made for fire-side roasting that can also handle larger outdoor foods. The SODEF Enamel Pan is the one to examine if you need stated induction compatibility, though its missing dimensions make fit harder to judge.
Get kitchen gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The choice comes down to more than material. Cooktop compatibility, handle style, and whether you roast indoors or over an open fire shape which pan makes sense. Perforations help hot air reach the chestnuts but limit everyday use; non-stick and enamel surfaces may simplify cleanup, while cast iron favors fire use but needs hand washing. I rank these five by how clearly their stated features serve different chestnut-roasting setups, and I flag the details each listing leaves unanswered.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- KitchenCraft is my best all-round stovetop choice, with a perforated base and stated gas, electric, and ceramic compatibility.
- Esschert Design FF156 is the clearest fit for open-fire roasting and outdoor grilling, but its stated care is hand wash only.
- SODEF lists induction compatibility, unlike the other explicitly described hob pans, but does not provide dimensions or capacity.
- IBILI combines a 26 cm steel body with a PFOA-free non-stick coating for electric, ceramic, and gas hobs.
- Victor offers a cast-iron body and handle for chestnut roasting, but its listing gives less information about use conditions and care.
| KitchenCraft Carbon Steel Chestnut Roasting Pan, 27 cm, Black |  | Best Overall for Stovetop Roasting | Material: Carbon steel | Width: 27 cm | Shape: Round | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Esschert Design FF156 Cast Iron Chestnut Roaster |  | Best for Open-Fire Roasting | Brand: Esschert Design | Model: FF156 | Material: Cast iron | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| IBILI 26 cm Non-Stick Chestnut Pan |  | Best Non-Stick Hob Option | Brand: IBILI | Model number: 450726 | Diameter: 26 cm | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SODEF Enamel Chestnut Roasting Pan, Induction Compatible, Black |  | Best for Induction Cooktops | Brand: SODEF | Model number: BDL-260519-673848-ENLT | Material/coating: Enamel | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Victor Cast Iron Chestnut Roaster |  | Best Dedicated Cast-Iron Alternative | Brand: Victor | Material: Cast iron | Finish: Unfinished | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| chestnut roasting pan | Material | Shape | Brand | Color |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| KitchenCraft Carbon Steel Ches | Carbon steel | Round | — | — |
| Esschert Design FF156 Cast Iro | Cast iron | Round | Esschert Design | Black |
| IBILI 26 cm Non-Stick Chestnut | Steel | Round | IBILI | — |
| SODEF Enamel Chestnut Roasting | — | — | SODEF | Black |
| Victor Cast Iron Chestnut Roas | Cast iron | Round | Victor | Black |
More Details on Our Top Picks
KitchenCraft Carbon Steel Chestnut Roasting Pan, 27 cm, Black
I put KitchenCraft first because it gives the clearest balance of chestnut-focused design and practical stovetop compatibility. Its 27 cm carbon-steel body has a perforated base intended to let steam escape, and the pan is listed for gas, electric, and ceramic hobs. That makes it a straightforward choice for many kitchens without asking buyers to infer whether a specialty pan suits their cooktop.
Compared with IBILI’s 26 cm non-stick pan, KitchenCraft offers a more explicit roasting mechanism: base holes for ventilation rather than a coated surface as its primary distinguishing feature. Its long wooden handle also gives it a different handling profile from the cast-iron Victor and Esschert roasters. The stated barbecue use for fish or vegetables provides some added flexibility, although the product is still designed mainly around chestnuts and should not be mistaken for a do-everything skillet.
The tradeoff is the open, perforated construction. It may be less suited to foods that release liquid or need a solid cooking surface, and its listed maximum temperature is 220 °C, a limit buyers should respect. At 0.44 kg, it is specified as a relatively light pan, but a long handle still needs room in a drawer or cupboard. If you mainly want to roast chestnuts on an induction hob, SODEF is the more relevant listed option; if you roast over a fire, Esschert is more explicitly aimed at that setting.
Pros:- Perforated base is designed to let steam escape during chestnut roasting.
- Listed for gas, electric, and ceramic cooktops.
- Long wooden handle helps keep the hand farther from the hot pan.
- Can also be used for fish or vegetables on a barbecue, according to the description.
Cons:- Its perforated, chestnut-focused design limits everyday skillet use.
- The stated maximum temperature is 220 °C.
- The wooden handle may require more careful storage and handling than a short all-metal design.
Best for: Home cooks with gas, electric, or ceramic hobs who want a clearly specified chestnut pan with a vented base and a long handle.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need induction compatibility, a solid everyday frying surface, or a pan rated above the stated 220 °C maximum.
- Material:Carbon steel
- Width:27 cm
- Shape:Round
- Handle:Wood
- Compatible cooktops:Gas, electric, and ceramic
- Maximum temperature:220 °C
- Item weight:0.44 kg
- Warranty:12 months
Our verdict“I recommend KitchenCraft to most non-induction stovetop cooks who want a purpose-built, vented chestnut pan with useful handle clearance.”
Esschert Design FF156 Cast Iron Chestnut Roaster
Esschert earns a distinct second place because it is the most clearly directed at roasting chestnuts over an open fire. Its cast-iron construction and round form suit buyers planning a fire-side session rather than simply adding a specialty pan to a stovetop collection. The description also says it can grill larger items outdoors, giving it a little more range than a chestnut-only tool.
Compared with KitchenCraft, this is the more compelling choice when the heat source is an open fire, while KitchenCraft provides more explicit compatibility for everyday gas, electric, and ceramic hobs. The 1.6-pound listed weight is worth noting for carrying or handling outdoors, and the cast-iron build distinguishes it from the lighter specified KitchenCraft pan. Buyers who want a non-stick surface for hob cooking may find IBILI a closer match, but IBILI is not listed for fire use.
The clearest drawback is care: hand washing is specified, so this is not a low-effort dishwasher option. The provided specifications also list an 11-liter capacity, but that number does not explain how much usable roasting surface the round pan provides or how many chestnuts fit in a single layer. I would not choose it solely on that capacity figure. For anyone who mostly cooks indoors, its fire-oriented identity may be less useful than IBILI or KitchenCraft; for open-fire cooks, that same specialization is the point.
Pros:- Explicitly designed for roasting chestnuts over an open fire.
- Cast-iron construction suits its stated outdoor roasting role.
- Description says it can also grill larger items outdoors.
- Round shape is purpose-built for roasting use.
Cons:- Hand wash only, according to the listed care instructions.
- Its open-fire focus is less relevant for buyers seeking a dedicated indoor-hob pan.
- The listed 11-liter capacity does not clarify usable chestnut surface or batch size.
Best for: Outdoor cooks who plan to roast chestnuts over an open fire and want a cast-iron pan that can also grill larger foods.
Not ideal for: People who mainly cook on a standard indoor hob or want dishwasher-safe, low-maintenance care.
- Brand:Esschert Design
- Model:FF156
- Material:Cast iron
- Color:Black
- Shape:Round
- Capacity:11 liters
- Weight:1.6 pounds
- Care:Hand wash only
Our verdict“I would choose Esschert over the stovetop-focused KitchenCraft or IBILI when open-fire roasting is the main job.”
IBILI 26 cm Non-Stick Chestnut Pan
IBILI is my pick for cooks who value a coated cooking surface and want a pan explicitly made for chestnuts on common non-induction hobs. Its 26 cm steel body is listed for electric, ceramic, and gas cooktops, while its PFOA-free non-stick coating sets it apart from the bare cast-iron Victor and Esschert options. That coating may appeal to someone who would rather avoid an unfinished or uncoated surface, although the listing does not specify coating durability or cleaning tools.
Compared with KitchenCraft, IBILI is close in stated diameter but trades a described perforated base and long wooden handle for a non-stick coating. KitchenCraft gives more information about ventilation and handle design; IBILI’s stronger differentiator is surface treatment. It also offers a clearer indoor-hob alternative to Esschert, which is specifically presented for open-fire use. Neither the supplied description nor specifications list induction compatibility, so induction users should look instead at SODEF, while checking its unreported dimensions before ordering.
There are meaningful limits. IBILI is hand wash only, so the coating does not mean dishwasher convenience. Its listed 1-liter capacity is not enough to establish how many chestnuts the pan will roast at once, and the product details do not state a maximum temperature or handle material. Buyers who want a wood-handled pan with a stated heat limit have more concrete information from KitchenCraft; buyers wanting cast iron for outdoor fire use should favor Esschert or Victor. IBILI makes the most sense when the non-stick finish is the deciding feature.
Pros:- PFOA-free non-stick coating is a clear alternative to uncoated cast iron.
- Listed for electric, ceramic, and gas hobs.
- 26 cm diameter gives a stated size for comparing storage and cooktop fit.
- Designed specifically for cooking chestnuts.
Cons:- Hand wash only.
- Induction compatibility is not listed.
- The specifications do not identify handle material or maximum temperature.
Best for: Cooks with gas, electric, or ceramic hobs who prefer a PFOA-free non-stick coating on a chestnut-specific pan.
Not ideal for: Induction users, dishwasher-dependent households, or buyers who need detailed capacity, handle, and temperature specifications.
- Brand:IBILI
- Model number:450726
- Diameter:26 cm
- Material:Steel
- Coating:PFOA-free non-stick
- Compatible stovetops:Electric, ceramic, and gas
- Shape:Round
- Capacity:1 liter
- Care:Hand wash only
Our verdict“IBILI is the better fit than KitchenCraft for buyers who prioritize a non-stick coating over a described perforated base.”
SODEF Enamel Chestnut Roasting Pan, Induction Compatible, Black
SODEF takes the induction-specific spot in this lineup: its description lists compatibility with induction, gas, electric, and ceramic stovetops. That broad heat-source list makes it the one to investigate first if an induction hob rules out the other explicitly described stovetop options. The enamel coating is presented as supporting even heat distribution and easier cleanup, and the pan is intended for chestnuts and other small foods.
Compared with IBILI, SODEF’s advantage is stated induction support and a surface described as enamel rather than PFOA-free non-stick. Compared with KitchenCraft, it does not have a specified perforated base, wooden handle, width, weight, or maximum temperature in the supplied details. Those missing measurements matter: a compact design is claimed, but a buyer cannot confirm its diameter, storage fit, or likely batch size from the listing information provided here. I would treat it as a promising cooktop match, not the most fully documented choice.
The tradeoff is uncertainty rather than an obvious limitation in the stated compatibility. The product details provide no dimensions or capacity, making it harder to compare with IBILI’s 26 cm and KitchenCraft’s 27 cm formats. They also do not specify care instructions or handle material. If you need a known-size pan, KitchenCraft or IBILI offers firmer measurements; if you need an open-fire roaster, Esschert has the clearer use case. SODEF’s ranking reflects its distinctive induction listing, tempered by the detail gaps that buyers should resolve before choosing it.
Pros:- Listed as compatible with induction, gas, electric, and ceramic stovetops.
- Enamel coating is described as supporting easy cleanup.
- Designed for chestnuts and other small foods.
- Compact design is stated to be easy to handle and store.
Cons:- Dimensions and capacity are not provided in the supplied product details.
- Handle material and care instructions are not specified.
- No stated maximum temperature is available for comparison.
Best for: Induction-hob owners seeking a chestnut pan listed for several stovetop types and willing to verify size and handling details.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need confirmed dimensions, capacity, handle construction, or care instructions before making a selection.
- Brand:SODEF
- Model number:BDL-260519-673848-ENLT
- Material/coating:Enamel
- Color:Black
- Compatible heat sources:Induction, gas, electric, and ceramic
- Intended use:Chestnuts and other small foods
- Unit count:1
- Dimensions:Not provided in the supplied details
Our verdict“SODEF is the lineup’s clearest induction candidate, but I would confirm its dimensions and care details before choosing it over the better-documented hob pans.”
Victor Cast Iron Chestnut Roaster
Victor suits buyers who want a straightforward, dedicated cast-iron chestnut roaster without the broader outdoor-grilling claim attached to Esschert. Its round body and cast-iron handle keep the listed construction consistent, and the unfinished finish distinguishes it from the coated IBILI and enamel SODEF. The supplied description identifies chestnut roasting as its purpose, but gives fewer details about heat-source compatibility than the other options.
That limited specification set is the main reason I rank it below Esschert. Both are cast iron, yet Esschert explicitly names open-fire roasting and outdoor grilling, while Victor’s listing simply describes it as designed for roasting chestnuts. Compared with KitchenCraft, Victor also lacks stated gas, electric, and ceramic compatibility, a given size, weight, or temperature limit. It may suit a buyer already seeking this traditional material, but I would not assume its use conditions from the material alone.
The cast-iron handle is a meaningful caution for handling: the listing does not describe a heat-resistant grip or other handle treatment, so buyers should follow the product’s instructions and use appropriate protection around hot cookware. The listing also advises checking product labels and directions before use, and says packaging may vary. No care instructions are supplied, so it is harder to compare upkeep with the hand-wash directions stated for Esschert and IBILI. Choose Victor for its dedicated cast-iron format, not for a specification record that answers every practical question.
Pros:- Cast-iron construction is stated for the body.
- Cast-iron handle matches the pan’s listed material.
- Round shape and chestnut-roasting purpose are specified.
- Unfinished finish offers an alternative to enamel and non-stick coatings.
Cons:- Heat-source compatibility is not specified in the supplied details.
- Size, weight, capacity, and care instructions are not provided.
- Listing advises checking product labels and directions; packaging may vary.
Best for: Buyers who specifically want a round, unfinished cast-iron chestnut roaster and are prepared to verify its instructions and use conditions.
Not ideal for: People who need confirmed stovetop compatibility, a stated size, clear care guidance, or a handle with a specified non-metal grip.
- Brand:Victor
- Material:Cast iron
- Finish:Unfinished
- Handle material:Cast iron
- Shape:Round
- Color:Black
- Number of items:1
- Listing guidance:Check product labels and directions before use
Our verdict“Victor is a focused cast-iron alternative, but Esschert is the clearer choice when open-fire use is the priority and KitchenCraft when stovetop fit needs explicit confirmation.”
How We Picked
I ranked these pans around the job named in the title: roasting chestnuts, not collecting general-purpose cookware. I looked first at whether each description identifies a suitable heat source, since an open-fire pan and a hob pan are not interchangeable choices for every kitchen. I then weighed chestnut-specific design details—such as perforations, listed roasting use, and stated compatibility—against handling and cleanup information.
The ranking also reflects how much a buyer can verify from the supplied product details. For example, KitchenCraft states its compatible hob types, base design, handle material, and maximum temperature; SODEF lists induction support and an enamel finish, but leaves out dimensions and capacity. That does not make one universally better: it means the fit is easier to evaluate for some setups than others. I distinguish stated specifications from reasonable use implications rather than filling gaps with assumptions.
Because the listings describe different materials and use cases, I do not treat every pan as a direct substitute. Open-fire suitability gives Esschert a distinct role, while the IBILI and KitchenCraft pans are clearer matches for common non-induction hobs. Victor’s cast-iron construction earns a place for buyers seeking a dedicated roaster, but its thinner listing supports fewer specific comparisons. I also account for tradeoffs: hand washing is specified for Esschert and IBILI, KitchenCraft’s perforated design limits its everyday range, and the SODEF listing does not give enough sizing detail to confirm how many chestnuts it can hold.
No claims here rely on personal testing, customer feedback, ratings, or unstated performance promises. I order the picks by the usefulness and clarity of their stated features for distinct buyers: first a balanced stovetop option, then open-fire use, followed by specialist alternatives for non-stick, cast iron, and induction needs. The final choice should still match your heat source, storage space, preferred cleanup routine, and the quantity you plan to roast.
| chestnut roasting pan | Material | Brand |
|---|---|---|
| KitchenCraft Carbon Steel Ches | Carbon steel | — |
| Esschert Design FF156 Cast Iro | Cast iron | Esschert Design |
| IBILI 26 cm Non-Stick Chestnut | Steel | IBILI |
| SODEF Enamel Chestnut Roasting | — | SODEF |
| Victor Cast Iron Chestnut Roas | Cast iron | Victor |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Chestnut Roasting Pans
I would choose a chestnut pan by matching its stated design to the heat source and the way you plan to handle the pan. A feature that helps one cook may be a drawback for another: holes can support ventilation but rule out some everyday cooking, while an uncoated cast-iron pan has a different care and handling profile from enamel or non-stick steel.
Start with your heat source
Check compatibility before comparing finishes. KitchenCraft and IBILI are listed for gas, electric, and ceramic cooktops; SODEF also lists induction. Esschert is explicitly described for open-fire roasting, while Victor’s supplied details do not specify its heat-source compatibility. Do not infer induction support or open-fire suitability from material alone. If your cooking plan spans several heat sources, favor the option whose listing names each one, and confirm the maker’s instructions for your exact setup.
Perforated, coated, or cast iron?
KitchenCraft’s perforated carbon-steel base is intended to let steam escape during roasting, a feature that separates it from the coated IBILI and enamel SODEF pans. IBILI offers a PFOA-free non-stick coating, while SODEF is described as enamel-coated and easy to clean. Esschert and Victor are cast iron. These details tell you what construction the listing provides, not a guaranteed result for every batch. Choose the design that fits your care preferences and cooking method; do not assume the surfaces have identical heat behavior or maintenance needs.
Handle length and safe handling
A long handle can help create more distance between your hand and a hot cooking surface, which is why KitchenCraft’s wooden handle is useful to note. The product details identify Esschert and Victor as having cast-iron construction, and Victor’s handle is specifically listed as cast iron. No grip temperature or insulating feature is stated for those handles. Follow the product directions, keep protective equipment nearby, and allow room for a handle to extend beyond a burner or cooking area. For fire-side cooking, confirm that the chosen pan and handle are intended for that use.
Check dimensions and batch size
Known measurements make it easier to compare storage and cooktop fit. KitchenCraft is 27 cm and IBILI is 26 cm; the supplied Victor details do not give a diameter, and SODEF’s description leaves out dimensions and capacity. Esschert lists an 11-liter capacity, but that alone does not state how many chestnuts fit across its roasting surface. If you plan to roast for a group, look for a usable diameter and consider whether chestnuts can sit in a suitable layer. Ask for missing measurements rather than relying on a vague compactness claim.
Treat care claims as part of the choice
Care instructions are uneven across these listings. Esschert and IBILI are hand wash only; the supplied details do not give care instructions for Victor, KitchenCraft, or SODEF. An enamel or non-stick description does not, by itself, establish dishwasher safety. Check the manufacturer’s care directions before use and cleaning. If you want minimal cleanup effort, compare the actual stated instructions rather than assuming that a coated pan requires no special care.
Match versatility to the job
Some pans have a second stated use, but none should be judged as an everyday skillet by default. Esschert is also described for grilling larger outdoor items, and KitchenCraft can be used for fish or vegetables on a barbecue. The other listings focus on chestnuts or chestnuts and small foods. More versatility can matter if you want one tool for seasonal outdoor cooking, while a narrowly focused design may suit buyers who only want a chestnut roaster. Consider whether perforations or a specialty shape fit the other foods you actually cook.
Resolve missing specifications before buying
Product listings do not answer every practical question. SODEF gives no dimensions or capacity; Victor lacks size, weight, and care details; and IBILI does not specify a handle material or maximum temperature. Where a detail affects safe use or fit, verify it with the product label or maker’s directions. For Victor in particular, the listing itself advises checking labels and directions before use. A clear specification record can be more valuable than an appealing material description when you need the pan to fit a particular burner or storage space.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which pan is the best fit for an induction cooktop?
SODEF is the only pan in this comparison whose supplied description explicitly lists induction compatibility. Its dimensions and capacity are not provided, so check those details before deciding whether it fits your burner and expected batch size. The IBILI and KitchenCraft descriptions list gas, electric, and ceramic cooktops but do not name induction.
Which chestnut pan is intended for use over an open fire?
The Esschert Design FF156 is explicitly described as suitable for roasting chestnuts over an open fire and for grilling larger outdoor items. Victor is also a cast-iron chestnut roaster, but its supplied description does not state fire compatibility. I would follow the specific product instructions rather than treating all cast-iron pans as interchangeable for outdoor fires.
Do perforations matter when choosing a chestnut roasting pan?
KitchenCraft’s base holes are described as allowing steam to escape, making the perforated design its main distinction from the solid-surface coated options. That feature is tied to chestnut roasting, but it may limit use with foods that need a solid pan surface. Compare that design with your intended cooking and do not assume every pan in the lineup has the same ventilation features.
Are any of these pans listed as dishwasher safe?
The supplied details do not identify any of these five pans as dishwasher safe. Esschert and IBILI specifically state hand wash only, while the other listings do not provide care instructions here. Check the manufacturer’s directions for KitchenCraft, Victor, and SODEF rather than inferring dishwasher safety from carbon steel, cast iron, or enamel construction.
Which pan is easiest to compare by size?
KitchenCraft and IBILI provide the clearest diameter measurements: 27 cm and 26 cm, respectively. Esschert lists an 11-liter capacity but not a diameter in the supplied specifications, and SODEF and Victor lack dimensions here. For storage fit or batch planning, a diameter is more directly useful than a capacity figure that does not describe the cooking surface.
Conclusion
My recommendation depends on where and how you roast. For most cooks using a gas, electric, or ceramic hob, I would start with KitchenCraft because its 27 cm size, perforated base, and long wooden handle are clearly described. If you prefer a coated surface on those same hob types, IBILI is the more targeted alternative, with a 26 cm steel body and PFOA-free non-stick coating.
For open-fire roasting, choose Esschert: its stated use is the closest match, and it also has an outdoor grilling role, though hand washing is required. Induction owners should investigate SODEF first, then verify its missing dimensions and care details. Victor is the choice for someone set on a dedicated cast-iron roaster, but I would confirm its heat-source instructions and handling guidance before use. Matching the pan to your heat source and checking the details each listing leaves out will do more to narrow this group than choosing by material alone.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
